Utopia

Thomas MoreJun 2015

3.9

Word count: 50K words
Chapters: 11

Summary

Robert M. Adams's celebrated translation of Utopia has been meticulously revised for the Second Edition of this Norton Critical Edition, as have the accompanying annotations. Backgrounds is designed to assist student readers in an appreciation of Utopia by shedding light on the different points of view contemporary with More's work. Included are new selections from Saint Benedict and Tasso, as well as a medieval satire on the land of Cockayne. The Humanist Circle, a carefully chosen selection of letters, includes another important contribution by Erasmus. Criticism includes five new thought-provoking essays by Alistair Fox, Edward L. Surtz, G. R. Elton, Northrop Frye, and Robert M. Adams. Also new are selections from two modern anti-utopias or quasi-utopias—Aldous Huxley's Brave New World and B. F. Skinner's Walden Two.

Editor's review

Utopia is not a social blueprint offering standard answers, but a carefully designed thought experiment. Through Raphael's travel account, More places common ownership, the organization of labor, religious belief, and the judicial system side by side on a single island, leaving readers marveling and continually asking: is this an ideal, or a satire of reality? The dialogue advances layer by layer, combining sharp criticism of the social ills of the time with irresolvable hesitation and irony, so it serves both as an introduction to political philosophy and as a close reading of Renaissance humanism. The Norton Critical Edition includes background materials and related documents, helping to situate More within the intellectual networks of the sixteenth century, so that "Utopia" need not be misread as a plan to be adopted wholesale. Suitable for courses, reading groups, or independent reading, in comparison with texts such as the Republic.

Who it's for

A good fit for

Students of political philosophy and the history of political thought who need to understand the utopian tradition and early modern imaginings of the state
Readers of history and literature interested in Renaissance humanism, early utopian socialism, and More's era
Readers who enjoy thought experiments and dialogue-form writing and are willing to discuss institutions, property, and justice in a reading group
Teachers who need teaching materials and background documents and wish to use the notes and appendices to organize classroom discussion

Not a good fit for

Readers expecting a conventional novel plot, character development, and a complete storyline may find the book dominated by argument
Readers hoping for a directly implementable set of social reforms or a management manual are likely to misunderstand the book's nature
Readers unwilling to engage with the sixteenth-century historical context and impatient with notes and background materials will find the book demanding

Reading tips

Read the editor's introduction and background materials first to understand More's era and his interlocutors before entering the main text, which reduces obstacles from names and allusions
Distinguish Raphael's descriptions from More's own counter-questions; mark as you read which passages are statements and which are irony or unresolved doubts
After finishing, list Utopia's institutional arrangements and their costs on a single page, then compare them with contemporary debates on property, labor, and fairness
If participating in a reading group, divide into groups to discuss "is Utopia an ideal or a satire," supporting judgments with textual details rather than merely stating conclusions

Copyright information
INTRODUCTION
DISCOURSES OF RAPHAEL HYTHLODAY, OF THE BEST STATE OF A COMM
OF THEIR TOWNS, PARTICULARLY OF AMAUROT
OF THEIR MAGISTRATES
OF THEIR TRADES, AND MANNER OF LIFE
OF THEIR TRAFFIC
OF THE TRAVELLING OF THE UTOPIANS
OF THEIR SLAVES, AND OF THEIR MARRIAGES
OF THEIR MILITARY DISCIPLINE
OF THE RELIGIONS OF THE UTOPIANS

FAQ

Is Utopia a novel?

It is usually not treated as a modern novel. It uses the framework of dialogue and travel narrative, interspersed with argument, satire, and descriptions of social institutions, and is closer to humanist political prose. Readers expecting a novel may be disappointed; only by reading it as a work of thought can one enter its mode of argument.

Is Utopia More's ideal society?

It should not be simply equated with it. More both displays the attractions of Utopian institutions and maintains distance through the narrator, irony, and unresolved questions. Readers should distinguish Raphael's claims from the author's voice and see the work as a controlled experiment against real social ills, not a reform program signed by More.

Can I understand it without a philosophy background?

Yes, but with the help of the introduction and notes. First grasp the core issues—property, labor, religious toleration, and justice—then deal with the names and allusions; do not try to pursue every irony at the outset. Clarify the dialogue structure first, then revisit More's reservations on a second reading.

Is the Norton Critical Edition suitable for self-study?

Yes, but with a reading plan. Beyond the main text there are background documents and criticism, and the volume is information-rich; reading it straight through is not recommended. Read the main text and introduction first, then selected appendices according to interest, using the materials to answer specific questions rather than as tasks that must be completed.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

Thomas More Author

Thomas More is the author of Utopia. Within the available records, public information about his life is quite limited: only his name, one surviving work, and the classification of that work under inspirational and personal growth are confirmed. His dates of birth and death, nationality, and full career are not recorded, so it would be inappropriate to dwell on his official career or private life. Utopia uses the framework of an imaginary island and, through a traveler's account, depicts a society with common ownership and orderly institutions, while contrasting it with the poverty and injustice of real systems. The book interweaves narrative and dialogue, combining satire with speculation in restrained yet deeply meaningful language. It inaugurated the later literary tradition of utopian and dystopian imagination, and its questions about social organization and public welfare remain thought-provoking today.