Darkening of the Light

Name: Darkening of the Light
ISBN: 9787573004703

Ma YongHainan Publishing House · ChinaJul 2023

4.0

Word count: 154K words
Chapters: 24
ISBN: 9787573004703

Report an error Find this book

Summary

This book is a collection of essays by Ma Yong on the historical experience of historical research, divided into two main parts: "The Experience of the Older Generation of Historians" and "My Historical Research." "The Experience of the Older Generation of Historians" introduces the historical research careers of predecessors such as Zhang Taiyan, Jiang Tingfu, Zhang Yinlin, Fan Wenlan, and Hu Sheng, the general social currents of thought that influenced their historical research, and the historical concepts and methods they upheld, and analyzes the value of historical masterpieces such as Qiu Shu and An Introduction to Qing Dynasty Scholarship and their place in the history of Chinese historiography. "My Historical Research" introduces some of Ma Yong's own methods and reflections on historical research, which readers in related fields can study and draw on.

With a bold and expansive scholarly stance, this book disenchants and preserves truth, reconstructing the overall thread of the successive transformations of modern history.

Editor's review

Mingyi is another major work by the historian Ma Yong after his Four Books on the Late Qing. This work is not an academic monograph in the traditional sense, but a collection of historical essays with profound thought and elegant prose. The title is taken from the name of a hexagram in the Book of Changes, meaning "the eclipse of light," an allusion to modern China's difficult transformation under the impact of the West. With his deep historical scholarship, Ma Yong abandons simple linear narrative and moral judgment, and instead probes deeply into the inner worlds and historical predicaments of many figures from the late Qing to the early Republic.

The greatest value of this book lies in its historical view of "sympathetic understanding." Through a reexamination of key figures such as Li Hongzhang, Zeng Guofan, Zhang Zhidong, Kang Youwei, Liang Qichao, and even Yuan Shikai, Ma Yong attempts to restore their real considerations and limitations within specific historical circumstances, rather than casually judging them from a present-day perspective. For example, his analysis of the reasons for the failure of the Self-Strengthening Movement goes beyond the simple triad of "technology-institutions-culture," pointing out the inherent conflict between the traditional governance system and modern industrial civilization, as well as the dilemmas faced by decision-makers under incomplete information and time pressure. This interpretation makes history no longer a black-and-white script, but a complex picture full of gray areas, contingency, and helplessness.

In terms of writing style, Ma Yong skillfully combines the rigor of academic research with the fluency of prose, making the book both intellectually deep and highly readable. His citations are rich, yet he is never burdened by historical sources, and can always distill grand issues concerning the fate of the age from details. For readers who wish to go beyond textbook conclusions and deeply understand the tortuous roots of China's modernization, Mingyi offers an excellent window. It does not provide simple answers, but inspires thought: in the "great transformation unseen in three thousand years," how a generation responded to the "eclipse of light" moment of collapsing beliefs and lost direction, and the gains and losses and lessons therein, still have profound significance as a mirror for the present.

Who it's for

A good fit for

Readers with a strong interest in modern Chinese history (late Qing to early Republic) who wish to go beyond textbook narratives
Readers who enjoy combining history with intellectual analysis and the process of deep reading and reflection
Readers interested in the evaluation of historical figures and the complexity of history, who are not satisfied with stereotyped interpretations
Readers engaged in research or study in the humanities and social sciences who hope to draw inspiration for historical writing

Not a good fit for

Readers seeking light entertainment, strongly plot-driven fiction, or popular history
Readers expecting clear, single historical conclusions or purely chronological accounts of events

Reading tips

It is recommended to first read the preface and table of contents to grasp the core meaning of the author's "eclipse of light" metaphor and the book's overall framework
While reading, you may refer to the basic historical sequence, but the focus should be on the author's distinctive analysis of specific figures and events
There is no need to rush through the book; it suits intermittent deep reading, and after each piece you may pause briefly to reflect on its relevance to the present

About the publisher

Hainan Publishing House China · Founded in 1985

Hainan Publishing House is a comprehensive publisher known for literary and intellectual works, covering foreign literature, philosophy, classics, world-famous works, classical poetry and prose miscellanies. Its catalog includes foreign literary classics such as Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina and Romain Rolland's Jean-Christophe, philosophical works such as Jean-Jacques Rousseau's The Social Contract: Expert Companion Edition, and Chinese classics and poetic studies such as Lu Xun's essays and prose collections and Wang Guowei's Renjian Cihua, as well as illustrated popular-science works like Fabre's Insects. The involvement of translators such as Zhong Shufeng, Fu Lei and Chen Xiaoqing reflects the publisher's emphasis on translation quality and expert guidance. Public information is limited, and the above is based mainly on the books in the catalog.

版权信息
序言：寻找新史学的传统
老辈史家的经验
老辈史家对近代中国历史叙事的调整
《訄书》与中国史学转型
《清代学术概论》说了什么？
蒋廷黻与中国近代史叙事
张荫麟与中国历史重建
吕思勉与中国通史研究与写作
范文澜与当代中国意识形态的构建
李约瑟与中国科学技术史
费正清与西方对中国的看法
唐德刚先生逝世十年祭
我的史学研究
六十年近现代中国人物研究
“历史三调”——甲午战争百年研究史的简述与思考
所谓新旧——重建“五四”历史叙事
新文化史在中国——过去、现在与未来
史学本质与史家责任
学科渗透与历史学本质
作为艺术的历史学
大众历史写作的意义与方法
互联网时代的历史研究与书写
马勇书房，保持精神与文化的流动

FAQ

How does this book differ from Ma Yong's other works (such as Four Books on the Late Qing)?

Four Books on the Late Qing is a systematic discussion of late Qing history, grander and more rigorous in structure; Mingyi, by contrast, is a collection of essays, more focused on the thought, choices, and predicaments of figures at historical turning points, freer in style and more speculative, and may be seen as an extension and personal reflection of the former.

Are the views in the book too much of a "rehabilitation" or defense of historical figures?

Ma Yong's starting point is not simple "rehabilitation," but rather "sympathetic understanding," that is, placing figures back into their specific historical context and understanding the constraints and logic of their actions. Its purpose is to present the complexity of history, break down black-and-white binary views of history, and encourage readers to think in a more three-dimensional way, rather than to conduct moral judgment or offer comprehensive defense.

Can readers without a deep historical background understand it?

Yes. Ma Yong's writing is clear and fluent, and necessary background is explained where needed. The challenge of this book lies mainly in the depth of its reflection rather than the sheer volume of historical facts. As long as readers have a basic understanding of modern history, they can follow the author's thinking. It will be a better reading experience to regard it as a work that guides you in how to "think" about history, rather than a textbook that instills historical facts.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

Ma Yong Author · China · 1956

Ma Yong, born in 1956 in Suixi, Anhui, is a researcher and doctoral supervisor at the Institute of Modern History, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. He has long studied modern Chinese history, modern Chinese cultural and academic history, and the history of Confucianism, and has published more than one hundred articles, with major works including Studies in Han Dynasty Spring and Autumn Scholarship, Three Thousand Years of Chinese Confucianism, Four Books on the Late Qing, and A General Survey of Chinese Civilization. His writing is distinguished by a broad historical vision, examining political upheaval, intellectual change, and social transformation within a single framework. The collection includes forty-one of his works, spanning historical nonfiction, biography, and philosophy. Representative titles include A General History of Modern China, Volume 4: From the Hundred Days' Reform to the Boxer Uprising (1895–1900); A Republican Remnant: A Biography of Zhang Taiyan; Rediscovering Modern China; and The Great Transformation of the Late Qing: Disorder, Conflict, and Decline. He has also written history for young readers and general audiences, such as Chinese History Lessons for Children and The Master Class in Chinese History: Selected Works of Ma Yong, balancing scholarly depth with readability.