Soliloquy Under Tradition cover

Soliloquy Under Tradition

No rating yet
Chapters
22
ISBN
9787505715493

Tags

Summary

Soliloquy Under Tradition is Li Ao's breakout work. It collects twenty essays he wrote between 1961 and 1963; the author selected and assembled them in 1963, and their publication in Taiwan aroused widespread controversy and made Li Ao famous. The word "soliloquy" in the title is the author's own account: the attitude of resistance and contempt for tradition in these pieces felt "rather lonely" at the time, and all these thousands of words could only count as a personal soliloquy. The subjects look like a "miscellany": some discuss men's love and bachelor life, some women's clothes and "Miss China," some a mother's dreams and family trivia, some the absurdity of the law, the survival or abolition of Chinese medicine, the authority of the old and the prospects of the young; essays such as "Old People and Sticks" and "Thirteen Years and Thirteen Months" directly address the older generation's suppression of the young and caused a sensation in Taiwan's literary world. Running through them all is Li Ao's distinctive frankness and relish for satire: he calls these writings "wild and rebellious goods," holds that writing matters for conveying meaning and that form need not be fussy, and insists that a grinning, flippant piece can still be an essay and that the seriocomic can still be a major work. Li Ao's style is concise, biting, and often humorous, with extremely clear judgments of right and wrong and of morality; he also frequently blends historical research, documentary citation, and essayistic technique, creating a highly recognizable style. The book's critiques of traditional ethics, the education system, ideas of love, and the situation of women were quite shocking in the social context of the time and set the tone for the "critic" role Li Ao would play for decades. Read today, it offers both a cross-section of Taiwan's intellectual atmosphere in the 1960s and a glimpse of a young writer's sharpness and bias as he used words to collide with preconceptions.

Editor's review

如果只读一本李敖的杂文,多数人会推荐这本《传统下的独白》。它是李敖的成名作,文章写于1961至1963年,作者自选自编,锋芒未加修饰,最能看出那个尚未被“李敖”这个名字包装起来的青年本色。 好读是它最直接的优点。谈独身、谈情书、谈“不讨老婆之不亦快哉”,一路谐谑,读来常令人失笑;忽然又转入《老年人和棒子》《几条荒谬的法律》,语气一变而为逼人的质问。嬉笑与怒火同在一页,这正是李敖所说的“狂叛品”:只要能达意,形式一概不计。 它的价值还在史料层面。书中对女性处境、中医存废、青年出路、法律条文的批评,是1960年代台湾社会心态的一份生动记录;而他把考据与杂文嫁接的写法,也被视为鲁迅之后杂文的一种新变体。 需要提醒的是,李敖的明白痛快同时也是他的局限:判断过于直接,少有犹豫与含蓄,读者若不认同他的立场,容易只看到咄咄逼人。但作为了解李敖其人其文的第一站,这本薄薄的集子几乎不可替代。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 对台湾1960年代思想文化氛围感兴趣的读者
  • 喜欢杂文、论辩文字与犀利文风的读者
  • 想了解李敖早期创作与其成名经过的读者
  • 对社会批评、传统与现代化议题有关注的普通读者

Not a good fit for

  • 偏好温和含蓄、抒情散文的读者
  • 对强烈主观判断与攻击性论辩文字反感者
  • 期待系统学术论述而非杂感的读者

Reading tips

  1. 先读《老年人和棒子》《十三年和十三月》,把握全书的核心冲突,再回头读谐谑一路的文章。
  2. 把每篇文章放回1960年代初的台湾语境中理解,避免用今天的议题框架直接套用。
  3. 可与其后的《独白下的传统》对读,看李敖如何从抒情性杂感转向历史考据式的文化批评。
  4. 读到尖锐处不妨停下来想一想反对意见,李敖的文字更适合当作辩论的对手而非结论。

About the publisher

China Friendship Publishing Company China · Founded in 1983

China Friendship Publishing Company is a comprehensive publisher known for its literary titles, covering classical Chinese literature, foreign literature, folk literature and cultural appreciation. According to the books in the database, its classical list includes celebrated dramas and novels such as The Peony Pavilion, The Romance of the Western Chamber and Strange Tales from a Chinese Studio, as well as note-style classics like Hong Mai's Rongzhai Suibi. In foreign literature it offers translations of Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment, Kawabata Yasunari's Snow Country and Anne Frank's The Diary of a Young Girl, involving translators such as Zeng Siyi. It also publishes The Complete Literary Works of Lu Xun and titles associated with the "Xue'er Shuguan" editorial group, balancing the collation and popularization of classic texts. Public information on its publishing features and plans is limited; the above is summarized only from the books in the database.

Contents

  1. Preface
  2. Preface to the Second Edition
  3. The Soliloquy of a Bachelor
  4. The Executioner of Love
  5. A Smug Love Letter
  6. If I Were a Woman
  7. Zhang Fei's Eyes
  8. On Miss China
  9. Starting from Complete Nakedness
  10. "The Joys of Not Taking a Wife" (Thirty-Three Items)
  11. Mother's Dream
  12. Mother, Younger Brother, Movies
  13. The Psychology of the Long Gown
  14. The Red Rose
  15. The Old Emperor and the New Emperor: A Fragment from the Late Yuan and Early Ming
  16. The Biography of Mr. Wuwei: Using the Character "Wu" as an Allusion
  17. The Conscripted Officer
  18. Amending the "Physicians Law" and Abolishing Chinese Medicine
  19. Several Absurd Laws
  20. Old People and Sticks
  21. Zhang Tianshi Can Take a Rest!
  22. Thirteen Years and Thirteen Months

FAQ

《传统下的独白》和《独白下的传统》是同一本书吗?
不是。前者是李敖1963年自选的二十篇杂文结集;后者是另一部以中国历史与传统文化为对象的文章集。1989年大陆首次授权出版时,出版家李昕曾将两书精选合并、删去部分篇章,以《独白下的传统》为名推出,因此早期大陆版本容易混淆。
这本书在大陆有哪些版本?
常见的有中国友谊出版公司2000年版(ISBN 9787505715493),2010年该社又将其作为新版《李敖大全集》第14卷出版(ISBN 9787505725683,并合入《独白下的传统》与《中国艺术新研》);时代文艺出版社2012年“李敖五十年唯一自选集”本(ISBN 9787538741209),东方出版社2025年亦有新版。
这本书适合作为了解李敖的入门读物吗?
适合。它是李敖的成名作,文章篇幅短、语言直白、风格特征鲜明,能较快感受到其文风与立场。若想进一步了解其学术性写作,可再读《北京法源寺》或他的历史研究著作。
书中的观点今天读来是否过时?
部分具体议题(如当年的法律条文、社会事件)已失去现实针对性,但关于传统与现代化、青年处境、性别观念的讨论仍有回响。阅读时宜分清哪些是时代语境的产物,哪些是对普遍问题的追问。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

More by the same author

Top rated in the same category