Bentham cover

Bentham

No rating yet
Chapters
9
ISBN
9780192876225

Tags

Summary

This book is a concise introduction to the thought of Jeremy Bentham by the British scholar J. R. Dinwiddy (John Rowland Dinwiddy). Bentham was the founder of utilitarianism and a pioneer of the British legal reform movement, and his influence extends across ethics, jurisprudence, political theory, and social and administrative reform. The book systematically traces the connections among the components of Bentham's philosophy: the principle of utility as the basic measure for judging law and government, extending from questions of punishment and judicial procedure to discussion of rights, obligations, and the logic of legislation, and also covering democratic constitutional proposals, parliamentary reform, and the clearing away of "fictitious" concepts and linguistic fog. The author also devotes considerable space to the various common scholarly interpretations of Bentham's thought, distinguishing what later generations accepted from so-called "Benthamism" and what they misread or distorted, and finally assesses the continuing relevance of his ideas to modern political and legal issues. Dinwiddy long served as editor of The Collected Works of Jeremy Bentham and had a deep command of the original sources, so although the book is short, it balances textual grounding with the thread of the problems, and is widely regarded as a reliable introductory work for entering Bentham studies. It is suitable as the first stop before studying Bentham's own works, and it also helps readers place Bentham in the intellectual-historical chain from Hume and Blackstone to Mill.

Editor's review

谈及功利主义,人们往往只记住“最大多数人的最大幸福”这句口号,却很少知道边沁究竟想拿它做什么。丁威迪这本小书的价值正在于此:它不是道德哲学的口号式介绍,而是把边沁当作一位“法律的工程师”来解读,看功利原理如何被用来重新丈量刑罚、证据、议会与行政机构。作者身为《边沁全集》主编,讨论原始文献时底气十足,对密尔、哈列维等经典批评的回应也相当克制、不偏袒。全书体量轻、线索清,既不回避边沁学说中的争议与冷峻之处,也不把他简化为一张功利计算表格。对于想认真读懂《道德与立法原理导论》却屡屡卡在术语与长句上的读者,先读这本导论,再回头读原著,往往会顺畅得多。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 想系统了解功利主义与边沁思想、但缺少哲学基础的普通读者
  • 法学、政治学专业学生,需要先建立思想史背景再读原著
  • 对社会治理、立法改革与公共政策理论感兴趣的读者
  • 需要在课堂上做边沁专题讲解的高校教师与读书会带领人

Not a good fit for

  • 只寻找现成道德结论、希望本书给出“该怎么做”答案的读者
  • 已深入研读《边沁全集》与大量二手研究、想要前沿争论的资深研究者

Reading tips

  1. 先读导论与功利原理两章,抓住核心概念,再回头细看法律与政治改革部分。
  2. 与《道德与立法原理导论》(时殷弘译,商务印书馆)对照阅读,导论看框架,原著看论证。
  3. 读完后找密尔《论自由》与《功利主义》中批评边沁的段落对照,形成自己的判断。
  4. 随时记下边沁对刑罚、证据、议会改革的具体主张,并与当下公共政策议题互相参照。

About the publisher

Public information on Oxford University Press is limited, yet the books held here indicate a publishing direction that spans philosophy of religion, Eastern philosophy, and foreign literature. The list includes the complete works of Zhuangzi, a classic of Daoism, alongside Henry Francis Cary's English translation of Dante's Divine Comedy, Mrs. Henry Wood's East Lynne, and a study of Bentham, as well as material related to The Economist. Authors represented include Zhuangzi, Dante Alighieri, Henry Francis Cary, Leonard N. Neufeldt, J. R. Dinwiddy, and Chris Fraser. Overall, the list reflects a balance between original-language editions and scholarly editions, and between classic texts and literary studies.

Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Bentham's Life and Intellectual Background
  3. The Principle of Utility
  4. Jurisprudence and Legal Reform
  5. Political Theory and Democratic Reform
  6. Interpretations and Controversies of "Benthamism"
  7. The Spread of His Thought and Its Modern Significance
  8. Suggestions for Further Reading
  9. Index

FAQ

这本书是边沁本人的原著吗?
不是。本书是 J. R. 丁威迪撰写的边沁思想导论,属于研究性二手著作,1989 年由牛津大学出版社出版。边沁本人的代表作为《道德与立法原理导论》,中译本由时殷弘翻译、商务印书馆出版。
书名 Bentham 容易与边沁原著混淆吗?
确实容易。市面上以“Bentham”为名的书有多种,例如菲利普·斯科菲尔德《Bentham: A Guide for the Perplexed》、迈克尔·奎因的《Bentham》等。本书作者为丁威迪,ISBN 为 9780192876225,请核对作者与书号再下单。
没有哲学基础能读懂吗?
可以。本书定位为简明导论,篇幅短、术语少,作者会先交代背景再展开概念。若遇到功利、制裁、虚构等术语,建议配合注释和原著的译者导言一起看,效果更好。
读完这本再读哪一本?
建议直接读边沁《道德与立法原理导论》(时殷弘译,商务印书馆),这是其代表作,系统阐述功利原理与刑事立法原则;若对全景敞视监狱感兴趣,可再查阅福柯《规训与惩罚》中的相关讨论。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

J. R. Dinwiddie is an author about whom relatively little is known; public information is limited, and basic details such as nationality, birth and death dates cannot currently be confirmed. According to the available bibliographic records, Dinwiddie has only one work to his name, namely Bentham, a study of the British philosopher Jeremy Bentham. The book is classified under philosophy, religion, and Western philosophy, indicating that it is oriented toward the study of philosophical thought, with a particular focus on Bentham's utilitarianism and the related political and ethical ideas. Although little is recorded about the author's personal life, this work can serve as an introductory or reference text for understanding Bentham's thought, and may be consulted by readers interested in the history of Western philosophy and the utilitarian tradition. In the absence of further biographical material, any assessment of Dinwiddie should be confined to the subject matter and scholarly orientation presented in the work, without excessive speculation.