Jie Tower: Remarks on Poetry and Lyric Poetry cover

Jie Tower: Remarks on Poetry and Lyric Poetry

Rating 3.5
Word count
25K words
Chapters
4

Tags

Summary

Traditional Chinese culture has a long history of thought, marked by a high degree of originality, inventiveness, and literary quality. Its early intellectual forms are highly distinctive: religious theology, classical texts of traditional Chinese medicine, ancient military strategy, Confucianism, Daoism, Buddhism, and the Hundred Schools of Thought, feng shui and metaphysics, the Twenty-Four Histories, local customs and geography—all are profound and extensive. This series, "Essence of the Chinese Classics: Original Texts," preserves the original appearance of the books and focuses on preserving and transmitting traditional Chinese thought and culture. By reading the literary essence left by ancient sages, readers can cultivate their temperament and quietly absorb the classics of Chinese learning.

Editor's review

Zijie Lou Shihua is a notebook-style work in which Lin Gengbai discusses poetry and ci. Published in the series "Essence of the Chinese Classics: Original Texts," it preserves the original appearance of the book. The shihua genre has always emphasized personal insight and evaluation, and this book continues that tradition: in short, essayistic entries it discusses poetry and ci, including judgments on and selections from poets and poems of successive dynasties, with a style that reflects personal temperament and the spirit of its era. Its strength lies in forthright, unconventional commentary: readers can see the distinctive eye of a modern literary figure for classical poetry and, through his remarks, reexamine familiar poets and works. It should be noted that shihua are mostly fragmentary reflections rather than a system, so readers should not judge the book by the standards of a literary-history textbook. Read it as a casual conversation with the author, dip into it at random, pause to think where something resonates, and compare the comments with the original poems to appreciate the interplay between commentary and text.

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • Lovers of classical poetry who want to hear one person's distinctive views
  • Readers interested in the modern shihua genre and the tradition of literati criticism
  • Liberal arts students with some grounding in classical poetry who want to broaden their critical perspective
  • Readers who prefer fragmented reading and enjoy dipping into notebooks

Not a good fit for

  • Beginners seeking systematic knowledge of poetry history or textbook-style explanation
  • Academic researchers expecting a rigorous theoretical system and detailed annotations
  • Readers with little interest in classical Chinese prose and subjective commentary

Reading tips

  1. Read primarily by dipping in; there is no need to follow the order, and when a poem entry interests you, look up the original poem to read alongside it.
  2. Keep a pen handy and note your disagreements beside the commentary, creating a dialogue with the author.
  3. For poets mentioned repeatedly, make a small thematic list and read the relevant entries together to see the critic's tendencies.
  4. After finishing, review the book and summarize the author's basic criteria for judging poetry, assessing both his insight and his limitations.

Contents

  1. 版权信息
  2. 孑楼诗词话
  3. 一
  4. 二

FAQ

What is shihua? What category does this book belong to?
Shihua is a traditional Chinese genre of essayistic writing on poetry, usually consisting of short notebook entries that comment on poets and poems and record anecdotes from the poetry world. This book belongs to that category; it consists mainly of fragmentary reflections and is not a systematic textbook on the history of poetry.
Can I understand it without any background in poetry?
The commentary often discusses specific poets and poems, so without some grounding in classical poetry, understanding will suffer. It is advisable to first become familiar with works by the common poets mentioned in the book, or to look up the original poems while reading; the experience will then be much smoother.
Can this book serve as an introduction to poetry?
Not really. Shihua emphasize personal insight and evaluation and lack systematic, step-by-step explanation. Beginners should first read works with annotations and a literary-historical framework, then return to shihua to better appreciate the subtlety of its remarks.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

林庚白 Author

Lin Gengbai is the author of the two works Libaolou Shihua and Jielou Shici Hua. Publicly available information about his life is limited: his nationality, dates of birth and death, and English name are not clearly recorded. Judging from the surviving works, he devoted himself to the shihua, or remarks on poetry, a form in which he commented on poets and their poems in informal notes, recorded anecdotes from the poetry world, and discussed the origins and development of poetry as well as the successes and failures of poetic composition. Writing of this kind usually values personal insight and judgment, proceeds in a free style, offers appreciation of individual works, and reflects on questions of poetics, providing a way to understand traditional modes of poetry criticism. In common classifications the two shihua are placed under Eastern philosophy and classic works, which indicates their position among readings on traditional culture. On the basis of the materials currently available, it is still difficult to sketch the full course of his life, and readers may begin with these two works to appreciate his critical eye and prose style.