A New Commentary on Argumentation cover

A New Commentary on Argumentation

No rating yet

Tags

Summary

A New Commentary on Argumentation is a work of annotation and collation centered on ancient Chinese thought on argumentation and logical method. Judging from the title and publication clues, the book was included by Zhonghua Book Company in a selected series and is a work of academic popularization that punctuates, annotates, and explains traditional texts on argumentation. Taking "argumentation" as its core object, the book either compiles or explicates chapters and entries in ancient classics concerning reasoning, debate, name and reality, and right and wrong, striving to present the face of China's classical tradition of argumentation to modern readers. The collator typically appends explanatory introductions, notes, and editorial remarks beneath the original text to explain the meaning of terms, the structure of arguments, and the documentary background, helping readers understand the expressive modes and intellectual threads of ancient argumentation. Zhonghua Book Company has long been known for collating ancient texts and publishing academic works; its annotated books generally prize reliable editions, cautious punctuation, and concise annotation, serving both researchers and general readers. This book presumably follows the same format, seeking a balance between fidelity to the original meaning and accessibility. It should be noted that, because verifiable bibliographic information is currently limited, this page leaves factual fields such as author, publication year, ISBN, and word count unfilled; for further details on the specific chapters and content structure of the book, readers are advised to consult Zhonghua Book Company's official publications or library catalog records.

Editor's review

中华书局出版的注释类古籍读物,一向以体例谨严、校注审慎著称。《论证新注》从书名看,正属于对传统论证文献进行现代整理的一类著作,适合对古代名辩之学、说理传统感兴趣的读者。此类书的价值,一在底本与标点,二在注释的深浅得宜:注得太简,读者不明所指;注得太繁,又易喧宾夺主。中华书局的整理本通常在二者之间把握分寸,既保留原文面貌,又以简明注释疏通文义、交代出处。对初学者而言,这类注本可以作为进入古典论理之学的门径;对研究者而言,也可借以核查文本、比较诸家之说。需要提醒的是,本书的具体作者、出版年与内容结构目前尚待核实,读者选购时宜核对版权页与目录。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 对中国古代逻辑与名辩思想感兴趣的读者
  • 需要研读传统论证文献的高校文科学生
  • 偏好中华书局古籍整理体例的藏书者
  • 希望借助注释理解古代说理文本的自学者

Not a good fit for

  • 只想阅读现代逻辑学教科书的入门者
  • 期待轻松故事类读物的休闲读者

Reading tips

  1. 阅读前先了解中国古代名辩之学的基本背景,有助于把握注释所指。
  2. 对关键术语随手标记,前后对照,体会古代论证的用词与结构。
  3. 遇到注释简略处,可参阅相关古籍原典与工具书互相印证。
  4. 把书中论证方法与现代逻辑常识作比较,形成自己的理解框架。

About the publisher

Zhonghua Book Company China · Founded in 1912

Zhonghua Book Company is a publisher known for collating ancient texts and academic publishing, with its output centered on Eastern philosophy, culture, classic works, art, and historical reading. Its library contains 532 titles, including Chen Shou's Records of the Three Kingdoms, Guo Qingfan's Collected Commentaries on Zhuangzi, the four-volume Chinese Literature: Four Great Classical Novels, and the two-volume Table of Seal and Clerical Script Forms from Qin, Han, Wei, and Jin. These titles span historical classics, commentaries on the philosophers, classical novels, and philological reference works. Representative authors include Chen Shou, Guo Qingfan, Wu Cheng'en, Shi Nai'an, Cao Xueqin, Luo Guanzhong, Xu Wenwu, and the Hanyu Dazidian character-form group, reflecting a focus on primary sources and scholarly editors. Its publishing character lies in combining authoritative editions and annotated texts with both accessible classics and specialized research. Public information on its fuller catalog is limited; this note describes only the directions evident in the library's holdings.

FAQ

《论证新注》是哪个出版社出版的?
据现有目录线索,该书由中华书局出版。具体版次与印次请以版权页为准,本页未核实到确切出版年。
这本书适合没有古文基础的读者吗?
书名含“新注”,通常意味着附有标点与注释,可降低阅读难度。但古代论证文献仍有一定门槛,建议初学者配合工具书与导读材料阅读。
为什么本页的作者和出版年等信息是空的?
本页事实字段须经核实方可填写,未能联网确认的信息一律留空,以免误导读者。请以中华书局出版物或图书馆书目记录为准。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

Top rated in the same category