Ciji Medical Talks
Tags
Summary
Ciji Medical Talks is a medical case and medical talk text by the modern physician Sun Ziyun. Completed in 1924 and published by the Beijing Shishan Society, it survives in two typeset editions, from 1924 and 1927 (other sources record completion in 1923 and a facsimile based on the 1923 typeset edition). The book has two volumes, and the commonly available facsimile edition runs to about 136 pages. A preface by the author explains that the book consists of Sun Ziyun's "usual informal talks on medicine, secretly heard and written down by his students"—that is, it was recorded and organized by disciples while they observed his consultations and listened to his lectures. Volume One is arranged by the four seasons of the guihai year (1923)—spring, summer, autumn, and winter—and repeatedly sets out the academic thesis that "the entire crystallization of the Inner Canon lies in grain qi" and that "earth corresponds to the spleen and stomach; all diseases arise from earth; when earth does not generate metal, metal cannot restrain wood; therefore in treating disease one must first take clearing the stomach, nourishing yin, and harmonizing the liver as the guiding principles." It stresses that the first priority in studying medicine is to read the Shennong Materia Medica and the Inner Canon closely, and only then to range widely through other books, learning from one another's strengths, without being bound by antiquity; and it discusses one by one the causes, mechanisms, and simple therapies of more than thirty miscellaneous internal diseases, interspersed with clinical experience in treating liver disease, cough, jaundice, sha eruptions, wool-fiber boils, winter warmth, and the prevention of spring pestilence, with appended "On Locating Acupoints" and "On the Blood and Qi of the Five Viscera and Their Nourishment." The upper part of Volume Two consists of lecture notes, using diagrams of the Supreme Ultimate, the Two Modes, the Four Images, and the Eight Trigrams to deduce the relations between the prior-heaven and posterior-heaven trigrams and the viscera, the twelve months, the five movements and six qi, and the five phases, five positions, and five qi. The lower part of Volume Two argues that the Materia Medica and the Inner Canon cannot be divided into separate schools, that studying medicine should correct the abuses of the times, value new knowledge, and proceed step by step; it also contains discussions of methods of formulating prescriptions, of examining symptoms by observing the seasons and causes of disease, and of the essentials of clinical practice, covering yin and yang, the five phases, wind, the five tones and five flavors, the nine orifices and the viscera, the exterior-interior pairing of the viscera, the membranes, dual contraction by cold, the kidney as prior heaven and the stomach as posterior heaven, sovereign fire and ministerial fire, the constructive and defensive qi, pulse diagnosis, and cold-heat deficiency-excess, with questions and answers distinguishing diseases and patterns, and also discussing gynecology, pediatrics, and comparisons between Chinese and Western drugs. The whole book embodies the author's clinical attitude of taking the classics as the foundation, not being bound by established formulas, and adapting to the times.
Editor's review
这是一部容易被忽略、却颇值得一读的民国医话。孙子云是川北汉中人,在北京实善社医学研究会主讲《本经》《内经》,本书即由门人听讲侍诊随手记录而成。因为“随手记录”,它少有精心雕琢的架子,读来像坐在诊室里听老先生讲课:读经、论脉、辨症、谈方,一层一层往下说,偶有锋芒,直陈时弊。 书中最可玩味的是“活”字。作者力主学医先精《本经》《内经》,却分明说“尽信书不如无书”,指古方由一时经验而得,宜于古未必宜于今,须随气候、人情之变而翻新。他以“土属脾胃”为纲,主张治病先清胃、养阴、和肝,并不怕与时说相左。卷二又把八卦、五运六气与脏腑相互参证,虽今日读者未必尽信,却可借此了解近代中医的理论想象与知识结构。 版本方面,此书无现代整理排印本广为流通,市面常见的是依据1924年、1927年北京实善社排印本的影印或复印本,字迹偶有漫漶。若把它当作文献来读、当作一位民国医家的思想样本来看,收获远胜于把它当作按图索骥的方书。书中屡言“治病当尽力而为”,用方不可过泥——这句话本身,就是本书最好的注解。
Who it's for
A good fit for
- 对民国中医文献与医话体裁感兴趣的读者
- 正在系统研读《内经》《神农本草经》的中医学子
- 想了解近代中医如何回应中西医之争的医史研究者
- 喜欢读临证随笔、愿意从“讲谈”中体会医理的中医师
Not a good fit for
- 想查找现成方剂、按病索方的初学者
- 需要现代规范校注、白话译文的入门读者
- 对五运六气、卦象推演等传统理论完全不感兴趣的读者
Reading tips
- 先读卷一的四季讲论,把握作者“谷气—脾胃”的总纲,再读卷二的理论部分。
- 卷二上篇的卦图与表格可对照书本中的图版看,不必强行记忆,重在理解其思路。
- 遇到病证论述时,可与《内经》《伤寒论》原文对读,体会作者“不泥古”的分寸。
- 笔记式随读随记:书中多为口语讲谈,前后互见,摘出反复出现的观点最见其学术主张。
Contents
- Preface to Ciji Medical Talks
- Volume One, Ciji Medical Talks (Spring of the Guihai Year)
- Volume One, Ciji Medical Talks (Summer of the Guihai Year)
- Volume One, Ciji Medical Talks (Autumn of the Guihai Year)
- Volume One, Ciji Medical Talks (Winter of the Guihai Year)
- Appendix: On Locating Acupoints
- Appendix: On the Blood and Qi of the Five Viscera and Their Nourishment
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagrams of the Supreme Ultimate, Two Modes, Four Images, and Eight Trigrams
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Physiology, Qi, and Numerology of the Supreme Ultimate
- Volume Two, Part One: The Successive Transmission of the Primary Trigrams and the Prior-Heaven and Posterior-Heaven Trigrams
- Volume Two, Part One: Extending from the Prior-Heaven and Posterior-Heaven Trigrams to the Key to the Viscera
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Viscera and Trigrams, One
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Viscera and Trigrams, Two
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Eight Trigrams Corresponding to the Twelve Months
- Volume Two, Part One: Table of the Six Qi Governing the Year According to the Earthly Branches
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Five Movements
- Volume Two, Part One: Diagram of the Correspondence of the Three Yin and Three Yang with the Eight Trigrams and Five Movements
- Volume Two, Part One: Table of the Five Phases, Five Positions, and Five Qi of Heaven
- Volume Two, Part One: Table of the Five Wonders, Five Phases, and Five Movements of Heaven, Earth, and Man
- Volume Two, Part Two: On the Materia Medica and the Inner Canon
- Volume Two, Part Two: Studying Medicine Should Not Divide into Schools but Should Take the Materia Medica and the Inner Canon as Its Foundation
- Volume Two, Part Two: Studying Medicine Should Correct the Abuses of the Times
- Volume Two, Part Two: Studying Medicine Should Value New Knowledge
- Volume Two, Part Two: The Steps of Studying Medicine
- Volume Two, Part Two: The Supreme Method of Studying Medicine
- Volume Two, Part Two: Methods of Formulating Prescriptions
- Volume Two, Part Two: In Antiquity There Were No Secret Formulas
- Volume Two, Part Two: Examining Symptoms Should Observe the Seasons and the Causes of Disease
- Volume Two, Part Two: Essentials of Clinical Practice
- Volume Two, Part Two: On Yin and Yang
- Volume Two, Part Two: On the Five Phases
- Volume Two, Part Two: On Wind
- Volume Two, Part Two: On the Five Tones
- Volume Two, Part Two: What the Five Flavors Desire
- Volume Two, Part Two: The Relation of the Nine Orifices to the Viscera
- Volume Two, Part Two: Explaining the Throat
- Volume Two, Part Two: The Exterior-Interior Pairing of the Viscera
- Volume Two, Part Two: Explaining the Membranes
- Volume Two, Part Two: Explaining Dual Contraction by Cold
- Volume Two, Part Two: The Kidney as Prior Heaven and the Stomach as Posterior Heaven
FAQ
《慈济医话》的作者是谁,成书于哪一年?
作者为近代医家孙子云。多数资料记其成书于1924年,也有资料记作1923年;现存1924年、1927年北京实善社排印本,市面所见多为据旧排印本影印的资料本。
这本书有现代整理排印本吗?
据目前可查的资料,此书没有广泛流通的现代校注排印本,常见的是图书馆影印本及旧书市场的复印本,购买或引用时应留意版本来源与清晰度。
书名中的“慈济”是什么意思?
“慈济”取慈悲济世之意,是民国时期中医社团、医书常用的命名方式,与作者在北京实善社讲医、施医的经历相呼应,并非佛教团体专名。
书中的八卦、五运内容今天还有用吗?
这部分属于近代中医借象数推演脏腑气血的一种理论尝试,今人未必尽信。读时可作为理解民国中医知识结构的材料,临床取法仍以卷一、卷二下篇的辨证论述为主。
Comments
Find this book
This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.