Mozi: Annotated and Translated cover

Mozi: Annotated and Translated

Rating 4.3
Chapters
40
ISBN
9787100047241

Tags

Summary

The Mozi is the collected writings of the Mohist school, active from the 5th to the 3rd century BCE. Mohism was a major school among the pre-Qin thinkers, once ranked alongside Confucianism as a prominent doctrine; it later fell into obscurity and has regained attention in modern times. Mozi: Annotated and Translated is a collaboration between Tan Jiajian and Sun Zhongyuan, two scholars long engaged in Mohist studies. It takes as its base text the fifty-three-chapter Mozi contained in the Daozang (the tenth year of the Zhengtong era, Ming dynasty), an early and relatively good surviving edition, and draws on a century of commentaries and existing translations from both sides of the Taiwan Strait to collate, annotate, and render the entire work into modern Chinese. It is a comparatively systematic and comprehensive annotated reading edition of the Mozi. The book divides the text by content into five groups: the first, from Cultivating the Self to The Three Arguments, outlines several aspects of Mohist thought; the second, from Exalting the Worthy I to Against Confucianism II, presents the core early Mohist doctrines of universal love, opposition to aggression, exalting the worthy, identifying with the superior, economy in expenditure, simplicity in funerals, the will of Heaven, clarifying ghosts, condemning music, and condemning fatalism; the third, from The Canon I to Lesser Selection, records ancient logic and scientific knowledge; the fourth, from Geng Zhu to Miscellaneous Defense, records dialogues and deeds of Mozi with his disciples and contemporaries; and the fifth, from Preparing the City Gates to Miscellaneous Defense, documents Mohist siege-defense tactics and mechanical techniques. For ease of reading, the annotators combine the four chapters The Canon I and Explanation of the Canon I, The Canon II and Explanation of the Canon II into two, renumbering the table of contents as chapters one through fifty-one and setting aside the Daozang sequence numbers first through seventy-one. Each chapter generally consists of the original text, annotations, and a vernacular translation; the annotations focus on glossing words and explaining names and institutions, while the translations strive to adhere to the original meaning and remain clear and readable. A preface discusses the origins and development of Mohism and the editorial principles of the volume, and a list of major references is appended. For the notoriously difficult Canonical Chapters, the annotations and translations also offer readers a way into their logical and scientific content.

Editor's review

读《墨子》,难点不止在文字。墨家既讲“兼爱”“非攻”这样的伦理主张,又留下《墨经》里形近天书的逻辑与科学条目,《备城门》以下的守城诸篇更是专门到近乎技术手册。一部好的注译本,主要的价值就在于把这三种面貌不同的文本都译得通、注得准。 谭家健、孙中原都是长期深耕墨学与先秦诸子的学者,两人的研究背景分别偏文学与哲学、逻辑,组合起来正好覆盖《墨子》的两端。本书以《道藏》五十三篇本为底本,参校诸家,注文以字词训释、名物制度说明为主,译文尽量贴住原意。更见用心的是体例上的处理:把《经上》《经说上》《经下》《经说下》四篇合成两篇,让一向被割裂的“经”与“说”重新对上,减少了读者来回翻检的麻烦;同时打乱《道藏》原有的篇序编号,改以今存五十三篇重新排序,全目录标为五十一篇,翻阅起来更顺。 商务印书馆的排印也照顾了阅读:原文、注释、译文层次清楚,正文之外附有前言与参考书目,既可通读,也可当作工具书查阅。作为《墨子》的常备读本,它兼顾了学术规范和入门可读性,适合愿意沉下心细读原典的读者。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 想系统通读《墨子》原文、需要逐篇注释与白话译文的读者
  • 先秦哲学、诸子学方向的学生与研究者,可作为常备参考本
  • 对墨家逻辑、《墨经》科学思想及古代守城技术感兴趣的读者
  • 读书会或国学课程中需要较为可靠译注本作为共读底本的组织者

Not a good fit for

  • 只想要轻松短篇普及读物、不愿面对大段文言原文的读者
  • 希望以现代议题解读墨学、偏重阐发而非读原典的读者

Reading tips

  1. 先读前言,了解《墨子》成书、版本与本书体例,再决定通读顺序
  2. 可按五组结构推进:先读“兼爱”“非攻”“尚贤”等论说篇,再进入《墨经》与守城诸篇
  3. 《经上、经说上》《经下、经说下》与《大取》《小取》最好对照注文慢读,不必求快
  4. 读时随手记下关键术语(兼、别、三表、天志等),便于前后互证

About the publisher

The Commercial Press China · Founded in 1897

The Commercial Press is a publisher known for classic works and academic publishing, with titles spanning Eastern philosophy, foreign literature, world history, social culture, and applied psychology. Its list includes classical commentaries such as Zhu Xi's Collected Commentaries on the Analects and Wang Bi's Commentary on the Zhouyi, as well as modern annotated translations like Zhuangzi with Modern Notes and Translation. In foreign literature it offers War and Peace and Crime and Punishment, while in world history it carries Braudel's The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II. Applied psychology is represented by Irvin D. Yalom's Existential Psychotherapy, and ethical texts include a Greek-Chinese-English edition of the Nicomachean Ethics. Its authors and translators include Zhu Xi, Wang Bi, Yalom, Braudel, and translators such as Huang Zheng, Zhang Yiling, Shen Dongyu, and Tang Jialong, balancing the editing of original texts with academic translation.

Contents

  1. Preface
  2. Cherishing the Worthy
  3. Cultivating the Self
  4. What One Is Dyed By
  5. Models and Standards
  6. The Seven Calamities
  7. Economy in Expenditure
  8. The Three Arguments
  9. Exalting the Worthy I
  10. Exalting the Worthy II
  11. Exalting the Worthy III
  12. Identifying with the Superior I
  13. Identifying with the Superior II
  14. Identifying with the Superior III
  15. Universal Love I
  16. Universal Love II
  17. Universal Love III
  18. Against Aggression I
  19. Against Aggression II
  20. Against Aggression III
  21. Economy in Expenditure I
  22. Economy in Expenditure II
  23. Simplicity in Funerals III
  24. The Will of Heaven I
  25. The Will of Heaven II
  26. The Will of Heaven III
  27. Clarifying Ghosts III
  28. Condemning Music I
  29. Condemning Fatalism I
  30. Condemning Fatalism II
  31. Condemning Fatalism III
  32. Against Confucianism II
  33. The Canon I and Its Explanation
  34. The Canon II and Its Explanation
  35. Great Selection
  36. Lesser Selection
  37. Geng Zhu
  38. Valuing Righteousness
  39. Gong Meng
  40. Lu's Questions

FAQ

这本书是原文加译文的全本吗?
是。本书以明正统十年《道藏》所收五十三篇本《墨子》为底本,逐篇给出原文、注释与白话译文,篇目覆盖今存全部五十三篇,是全书的校勘注译本。
为什么目录是五十一篇而不是五十三篇?
注译者把《经上》与《经说上》、《经下》与《经说下》四篇并作两篇,方便“经”与其“说”对照阅读,因此目录标为第一至五十一篇,并且不沿用《道藏》本篇名下的原顺序号。
《墨经》部分读不懂怎么办?
《墨经》向来以文句简奥著称。本书对《经上、经说上》《经下、经说下》以及《大取》《小取》均有注释与译文,建议先看注释再读译文,并与相关条目对照,必要时参阅书后参考书目中的专门研究。
这本书和孙中原其他墨学著作有何不同?
孙中原另有《墨学通论》《墨子鉴赏辞典》等偏研究、鉴赏的著作,本书则是与谭家健合作、以校勘注译为主的全本读本,重点在提供可读的原文与译文,而非专题论述。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

孙中原 Author

Sun Zhongyuan is an author active in Chinese-language publishing whose works touch on Eastern philosophy, culture, and management. Public information about him is limited, and the available details come mainly from his four published books. In Guanzi, he organizes and interprets this pre-Qin classic, showing an interest in ancient Chinese intellectual resources. Mohism and Real-World Culture and The Art of Thinking of Chinese Ancient Sages connect Mohist thought and the reasoning methods of early Chinese thinkers with contemporary cultural topics; the style leans toward accessible explanation and lively interpretation rather than dense scholarly textual criticism. His other book, Fundamentals of College Student Innovation and Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice, is a management-oriented work aimed at innovation and entrepreneurship education in higher education. Overall, his writing addresses general readers, seeks to link traditional thought with present-day issues, spans a fairly wide range of subjects, and combines popular philosophy and culture with practical guidance.

More by the same author

Top rated in the same category