Corrections of Errors Ancient and Modern cover

Corrections of Errors Ancient and Modern

No rating yet

Tags

Summary

"Corrections of Errors Ancient and Modern" is a work of medical case records and physician's notes compiled by Xu Fulin and others, published in February 1985 by Hunan Science and Technology Press. The book collects 194 medical cases of erroneous and failed treatment across various specialties by famous physicians of successive dynasties. Its focus is not "how to cure a disease" but "how to clean up after a mistake": it presents both how erroneous and failed treatments occurred and how physicians identified the pathogenesis and corrected the deviation, turning the condition from danger to safety. The book is organized by category according to the cause of error, such as erroneous use of the sweating method, erroneous use of purgation, and erroneous use of warming, cold-cooling, diuresis and dispersion, tonification, drying and astringency, as well as errors by patients themselves. Each case first lists the case name and the attending physician, then recounts the illness and the diagnostic and treatment process, followed by the original book's commentary and the editors' commentary; the former preserves earlier insights, while the latter points out where the error lay and where the rescue lay, allowing readers to see the turning points in diagnostic reasoning through comparison. The book ends with an appendix, "Song of a Hundred Errors in Medicine," which summarizes in verse form the errors easily committed in clinical practice and can serve as an outline of the whole book. The value of such "negative medical cases" lies in this: successful cases are easily taken as fixed rules, but erroneous cases expose the danger of mechanically applying set formulas without distinguishing deficiency and excess, cold and heat, or constitution. The book repeatedly shows that errors mostly arise from incomplete four-diagnosis examination and unclear distinction of yin-yang, deficiency and excess, while rescue depends on carefully adhering to the pathogenesis and adapting to the pattern. For today's readers of medical cases, it is both a compilation of error-correction experience across the ages and a reminder—in clinical practice one must carefully examine deficiency and excess, cold and heat, be familiar with the properties of medicinals, and never recklessly apply purgation, tonification, warming, or cooling based on biased fixed methods.

Editor's review

中医医案书多如牛毛,但大多教人“这样治好了”;这本书反过来教人“治错了怎么办”。徐复霖把历代名家笔下的误治、失治病案汇为一编,一百九十四则,按误汗、误下、误温、误清、误补、误涩与病家自误等类别排列,等于给临床者画了一张“常见踩坑地图”。 最见功力的是编排体例:一案之中,既有原始病情的曲折,又有前人按语,还有编者按语层层剥开——错在辨证不细,还是错在药性不明,抑或错在拘泥成方?读者跟着走一遍,比读十条成功经验更记得住。书末《医中百误歌》更是提纲挈领,朗朗上口,适合反复诵读。 此书1985年由湖南科学技术出版社初版,属老一辈学者整理的实用型医案读物,语言平实、不炫理论,对今天的中医临床与文献学习仍有参考价值。需要说明的是,本书所收为历代医案,读时须留意时代与剂量背景,不可直接照搬方药。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 中医临床医师,尤其是内科、儿科、妇科门诊工作者
  • 中医医案与中医文献方向的研究生、本科生
  • 已学完中医基础理论、方剂学,想提高辨证纠偏能力的学习者
  • 对中医误治与医疗安全议题感兴趣的医史爱好者

Not a good fit for

  • 完全没有中医基础的普通读者,术语与病机分析门槛较高
  • 希望直接查方抓药、照方治病的读者
  • 只寻求养生保健常识、不关心临床辨证的人群

Reading tips

  1. 先读卷末《医中百误歌》,建立全书“易犯之误”的框架,再回头读各类医案。
  2. 按类别对读:把同属误汗或误下的几则案例连读,比较出错环节与救误思路的异同。
  3. 每读一案,先掩去按语,自行判断错在何处,再看原按与编者按,检验自己的辨证。
  4. 把书中药量与时代背景分开看,重点学辨机思路,勿直接照搬古方剂量。

About the publisher

Hunan Science & Technology Press China · Founded in 1979

Hunan Science & Technology Press has long focused on science popularization and medical publishing, balancing academic depth with accessibility for general readers. Among the 462 titles in the database are Richard Feynman's classic lectures on QED, the nature of physical laws, and relativity in the "Approaching Feynman" series, as well as general-audience works such as George Gamow's One, Two, Three... Infinity and Sean Carroll's The Big Picture. Its paleontology and dinosaur list includes Gregory S. Paul's Princeton field guides and authors such as Xing Lida. Hermann Weyl's Symmetry further reflects the press's attention to classic works bridging science and the humanities. Overall, the publisher shows a clear author profile and an emphasis on illustrated, well-rounded science publishing across both translated and original titles.

FAQ

《古今救误》是谁写的,哪一年出版?
由徐复霖等编著,1985年2月由湖南科学技术出版社出版第1版,属医案医话类中医著作,收录历代误治、失治医案一百九十四则。
这本书和《误治挽救录》是同一本书吗?
不是。《古今救误》为徐复霖等编,1985年湖南科学技术出版社出版;《误治挽救录》为刘正江编著,2021年中国科学技术出版社出版,二书题材相近但作者、体例与内容均不同。
书中按什么方式分类编排?
按致误原因分类,如误用汗法类、误用攻下类,另及误用温法、寒凉、渗消、补法、燥涩和病家自误等,共九类,书末附《医中百误歌》。
没有中医基础能读懂吗?
难度较大。书中涉及阴阳虚实、卫气营血、方剂化裁等专业内容,按语又多引古人文言,建议先具备中医基础理论与方剂学基础再读。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

Top rated in the same category