Ten Maxims Encouraging Reading

唐宗海Jun 2024

2.8

Word count: 2.1K words
Chapters: 2

Summary

Where a trend is so deeply entrenched that it cannot easily be reversed, suddenly depriving people of what they love would astonish the world and raise doubts; so let me now discuss it in plain terms. The understanding of medicinal properties begins with Shennong's Materia Medica, discussion of illness begins with the Ling Shu and Su Wen, and treating illness with medicines begins with Yiyin's Decoction Liquid. Then, when Zhang Zhongjing appeared in the Han dynasty, he collected the classical formulas transmitted from the sage Yiyin and from high antiquity and composed the two books Shanghan Lun and Jinkui Yuhan Jing; it is said there was also a Xiaopin, now lost. Compared with examination candidates, these are no different from the Four Books—yet some still doubt them. Can the Four Books also be unreadable? Therefore, reading Master Zhongjing's books is made the first exhortation.

Editor's review

Tang Zonghai was a late Qing physician, and this book, though titled "Ten Exhortations to Read," is in fact a clearly itemized introductory reading guide to medicine. The author begins with the Shennong Bencao Jing on medicinal properties, the Ling Shu and Su Wen on illness, and Yiyin's Tangye on the beginning of drug use, then advances to Zhang Zhongjing's Shanghan Lun and Jinkui Yuhan Jing, layer by layer outlining the knowledge genealogy of Chinese medical classics. His core claim is to regard Zhongjing's books as the "Four Books" of examination candidates, establishing his argument as the "first exhortation," with a clear and somewhat polemical stance. The writing is plain and accessible and makes good use of analogy, breaking down the deeply entrenched problem of scholarly habits into concrete, debatable book titles, so that it does not feel dull to read. For readers who want to understand how traditional medicine canonized itself and how bibliography was used to encourage study, this is a short text with high information density; it can also be used as a "road map" before studying Chinese medical classics, helping to establish a reading order of materia medica first, then medical theory, then classical formulas.

Who it's for

A good fit for

General readers interested in the genealogy of Chinese medical classics who want to understand the order of introductory reading
Students of Chinese medical history or bibliography who need to examine Qing physicians' ideas on encouraging study
Beginners who have encountered the Shanghan Lun but lack an overall bibliographic framework

Not a good fit for

Readers expecting specific formula compositions and clinical operating guidelines
Readers completely unfamiliar with Chinese medical terminology who want only popular health-preservation reading

Reading tips

Read through the whole text first and mark every title the author mentions, forming a personal reading list.
Read selected chapters of the Shanghan Lun alongside it to appreciate why the author makes Zhongjing the "first exhortation."
Pay attention to the passages analogizing examination candidates, and consider the relationship between medical canonization and examination culture.

版权信息
劝读十则

FAQ

Is this book a clinical diagnosis and treatment manual?

No. It is exhortative and bibliographic in nature, focusing on explaining which classics should be read and in what order, rather than teaching specific pattern-based prescriptions. To learn clinical practice, one needs textbooks and medical case records as well.

Can it be read without a foundation in Chinese medicine?

Yes, but patience is needed. The text involves titles and basic concepts such as the Shennong Bencao Jing, Ling Shu, Su Wen and Shanghan Lun, and some prior familiarity will make it smoother; even without understanding the terminology, one can grasp its exhortative approach and argumentation.

Why compare Zhongjing's books to the Four Books?

The author uses the "Four Books" that examination candidates must read as an analogy, emphasizing the foundational and orthodox status of Zhongjing's books in medicine, thereby responding to contemporaries' doubts about whether the classics are readable; this is a rhetorical strategy to enhance persuasiveness.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

唐宗海 Author

Tang Zonghai was a renowned physician of the late Qing dynasty, best known for his research on blood disorders, and his scholarly influence has endured to this day. The library holds five of his works, including Xuezheng Lun (On Blood Disorders), Bencao Wenda (Questions and Answers on Materia Medica), Yixue Jianneng (Practical Medical Knowledge), and Quandu Shize (Ten Rules for Reading). Among them, Xuezheng Lun is especially influential: devoted to the causes, mechanisms, and treatments of various bleeding conditions, it is carefully organized and combines theory, method, formulas, and medicinals, making it an important monograph in the study of blood disorders in Chinese medicine. Bencao Wenda discusses the nature, flavor, and functions of drugs in a question-and-answer format, making it accessible to beginners, while Yixue Jianneng is an introductory primer written in plain language and focused on practical use. Quandu Shize offers guidance on how to read and study. Tang Zonghai's writings are grounded in clinical practice and the pursuit of verified results, with clear prose that inherits traditional medical theory while emphasizing practical application; they remain a valuable reference for later clinical practice and education in Chinese medicine. Because public information is limited, details of his life, including exact birth and death years, native place, and teachers, are not recorded here.