Querying Cold Damage cover

Querying Cold Damage

No rating yet
Chapters
27
ISBN
9787533524951

Tags

Summary

Querying Cold Damage is a medical treatise completed in 1944 by the modern renowned physician Zhu Weiju (1884–1951) and his disciple Chen Susheng in the form of questions and challenges. It was first titled Records of Questions and Answers Within the Master's School and later arranged and given its present title. The whole book runs as a dialogue between master and disciple: Chen Susheng raises doubts, and Zhu Weiju answers them one by one, systematically discussing the six-channel system, the nature of pathogenic factors, the stages of disease, and therapeutic principles in the Treatise on Cold Damage. Grounded in clinical practice, Zhu Weiju held that Chinese medicine is a medicine based on healthy qi, that the six-channel patterns are six major categories of patterns arising as the body's healthy qi resists pathogens, and that these can be summarized into five stages—beginning resistance, insufficient resistance, excessive resistance, deficient resistance, and final resistance—the so-called "five-stage theory of cold damage." He was also the first to summarize diagnostic principles with the "eight principles," forming the "five stages and eight principles" doctrine. In treatment he emphasized supporting healthy qi and warming yang with warm-heat medicinals, making frequent use of aconite and other yang-warming drugs, and thus was known as "Aconite Zhu." The book also questions the warm disease school's views on cause, interception, and reversal, advocates communication and mutual learning between Chinese and Western medical theory, and includes in its appendix his proposal for establishing an "experimental hospital of Chinese medicine." It is an important document for studying the modern transformation of Chinese medicine and the thought of the Fire Spirit school.

Editor's review

读《伤寒质难》,最容易被它“不像医书”的样貌吸引:这不是一部从头到尾自说自话的论著,而是一场持续数年的师徒辩难。陈苏生步步追问,祝味菊层层作答,许多在今天看来仍属棘手的问题,比如六经究竟对应什么、温病与伤寒能否统一、邪正关系如何把握,都在往复语锋中被逼出答案。祝味菊学贯中西,曾赴日本考察医学,因此他的“中西医汇通”不是口号式的并置,而是从“治人”与“治病”的根本差异入手,重新解释六经与正气的关系,提出“五段论伤寒、八纲论杂病”的框架。其温热扶阳、善用附子的主张,为后世火神派所推重;而对温病学派截断、逆转之说的质疑,也保留了近代中医内部争鸣的真实声音。本次整理保留仿宋与宋体区分问答的版式,并附《创设“中医实验医院”建议书》,读者既能读到学术,也能读到一位近代医家对中医前途的焦虑与担当。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 已通读《伤寒论》原文、希望深入理解六经实质的中医学习者。
  • 关注火神派与扶阳学术思想、想追溯其近代源头的临床中医师。
  • 研究近代中医史与中西医汇通思潮的医史、文献研究者。
  • 喜欢问答体、希望在辩难中理解辨证思路的中医爱好者。

Not a good fit for

  • 完全没有中医基础、尚未接触过《伤寒论》的入门读者。
  • 希望直接查找成方与用药剂量的临证速查者。
  • 只接受现代教科书式表述、不愿面对学派争鸣的读者。

Reading tips

  1. 先读“伤寒五段大纲篇”与“发凡篇”,把握全书的问题意识与基本框架,再按篇回读。
  2. 阅读时对照《伤寒论》相关条文,留意祝味菊如何把六经转化为机体抵抗的不同程度。
  3. 对温热扶阳与附子用法感兴趣者,可配合火神派其他著作参照,但不宜脱离辨证自行套用方药。
  4. 书中对温病学的批评带有鲜明的时代与论辩色彩,建议同时参阅温病学原著以作平衡。

Contents

  1. Preface by Zhou
  2. Preface by Xu
  3. Preface by Lanna
  4. Preface by Lu
  5. Preface by Qin
  6. Preface by Zhang
  7. Author's Preface
  8. Part One: Introduction
  9. Part Two: Distinguishing Organic from Inorganic Pathogenic Factors
  10. Part Three: Incubation Period
  11. Part Four: Prodromal Period
  12. Part Five: Progressive Stage
  13. Part Six: Extremity Stage
  14. Part Seven: Decline and Convalescence
  15. Part Eight: Outline of the Five Stages of Cold Damage
  16. Part Nine: Greater Yang
  17. Appendix: Distinguishing Warm-Heat Disease
  18. Part Eleven: Lesser Yang, Part One
  19. Part Twelve: Lesser Yang, Part Two
  20. Part Thirteen: Yang Brightness, Part One
  21. Part Fourteen: Yang Brightness, Part Two
  22. Part Fifteen: Lesser Yin, Part One
  23. Part Sixteen: Lesser Yin, Part Two
  24. Part Seventeen: Reverting Yin, Part One
  25. Part Eighteen: Reverting Yin, Part Two
  26. Postscript
  27. Appendix: Proposal for Establishing a "Chinese Medicine Experimental Hospital"

FAQ

《伤寒质难》的书名是什么意思?
“质难”即质疑问难。全书由弟子陈苏生向祝味菊提出疑问、祝味菊作答,采用类似《内经》的问答体裁,故取名《伤寒质难》,初名《师门问答录》。
这本书和《伤寒论》是什么关系?
《伤寒质难》不是《伤寒论》的注释本,而是祝味菊借《伤寒论》六经体系阐发自己学术观点的论著,提出“五段论伤寒、八纲论杂病”,并以温热扶阳为治法特色。
“祝附子”这个称呼怎么来的?
祝味菊治病首重阳气,认为阳衰一分则病进一分,临证善用附子等温热药,取效显著,故同侪与患者称他为“祝附子”或“祝火神”。
这本书有哪些版本?
常见版本包括福建科学技术出版社2005年版(民国名医著作精华丛书)、学苑出版社2011年版(近代名医伤寒论著十人书)、人民军医出版社2007年版《伤寒质难:火神师门问答录》以及中国中医药出版社2021年版。
书末附录的“中医实验医院”建议书讲什么?
该建议书主张以科学方法验证中医理论、设立实验性中医医院,反映祝味菊融会新知、以实证推动中医革新的主张,是理解其学术抱负的重要材料。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

祝味菊 Author

Zhu Weiju was a renowned Chinese medicine physician of the Republican era. Public information about his life, nationality, and dates of birth and death is limited, and he is known today mainly through his surviving medical writings. The library holds one work by him, Questions on Cold Damage: A Record of Questions and Answers from the Fire Spirit Master's School, classified under medicine. The book discusses the diagnosis and treatment of cold damage in a question-and-answer format, examining the six channels, pattern differentiation, and the use of medicinals. It reflects a tradition of master-to-disciple instruction and clinical exchange, with a direct, practical style that shows the author's medical orientation toward valuing yang qi and favoring warm, hot-natured remedies. For readers studying modern Chinese medicine's cold damage theory and the academic lineage of the Fire Spirit school, the work offers relatively direct primary material and reveals Zhu Weiju's place in the transmission of Chinese medical learning.

陈苏生 Author · Chinese

Chen Susheng was a clinical practitioner of traditional Chinese medicine in the modern and contemporary period, long engaged in diagnosing and treating miscellaneous internal diseases. Publicly available information about his life is limited: his birth and death years, native place, education, and lineage are all unknown, and only one of his works is currently held in the collection, namely Difficulties in the Shanghan Lun: A Record of Questions and Answers from the Huoshen Master's School. Written in a question-and-answer format, the book discusses contentious points in Shanghan (Cold Damage) doctrine and reflects an approach that values the classics while remaining grounded in clinical practice, with a style combining oral transmission within a master's school and careful analysis. Because biographical material on Chen is scarce, readers can come to know him mainly through the diagnostic reasoning and clinical experience presented in this medical work. His writing offers some reference value for studying the transmission and clinical application of modern Shanghan scholarship in Chinese medicine.

More by the same author

Top rated in the same category