Drawing from Antiquity on Cold Damage cover

Drawing from Antiquity on Cold Damage

No rating yet
Chapters
6

Tags

Summary

Drawing from Antiquity on Cold Damage is a monograph on Cold Damage studies compiled by the modern physician Zhou Qiyin (1897–1968; original name Lichuan; native of Yin County, Zhejiang). Completed in 1932, it was printed by the Siming Yiyi Book House in 1933, with prefaces by physicians Zhang Shanlei (Zhang Shouyi) and Liu Ruideng. The book takes the then-newly emerged Hunan ancient text of Treatise on Cold Damage and Miscellaneous Diseases (known as the "Xiang ancient text") as its base and compares it clause by clause with the received Song edition of Treatise on Cold Damage, aiming to "supplement the Song edition's omissions and correct the errors of past commentators." It is divided into three volumes: the upper volume covers the pulse method and the cold damage preface; the middle covers warm disease, summerheat stroke, heat disease, dampness disease, and the diagnosis and treatment of cold damage; the lower covers the six channels of cold damage and the various "may and may not" chapters. The book collects 165 lost passages absent from the Song edition, corrects 79 errors in the received text, and includes lost formulas (recorded variously as 80 or 88, several fewer than in the Xiang text), with Zhou's interlinear notes explaining formula meanings. It is the first systematic collation monograph after the Xiang ancient text appeared, pioneering the "collate the present with the ancient" research path, preserving chapters such as the Cold Damage Preface and Pulse Differentiation, and using the ancient text to cross-verify with the Inner Canon and Classic of Difficulties, advancing later research on ancient texts such as the Baiyun Ge edition. It holds dual value in textual scholarship and clinical reference in modern Cold Damage studies.

Editor's review

这是一本“冷门但重要”的民国伤寒学著作。1932年湘古本《伤寒杂病论》甫一问世,周岐隐即以之校勘宋本,一年而成《伤寒汲古》,其反应之快、用功之勤,在近代医家中颇为少见。 本书的可贵处有三:一是“以古校今”的方法自觉,把古本从“奇物”变成了校勘工具;二是体例清爽,佚文、订误、佚方分卷罗列,读者可对照宋本逐条核查,不必在长篇注疏中翻检;三是注语简省,周氏不喜后人过度发挥,读来少了许多玄虚。 需要提醒的是,古本《伤寒论》的真伪至今仍有争议,书中所辑“佚文”并非毫无问题;但正因如此,本书恰好是观察民国医家如何面对“新出古本”的绝佳标本。对于研究《伤寒论》版本流传、条文校勘与近代中医学术史的读者,它的价值远超其篇幅。

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • 研究《伤寒论》版本与条文校勘的中医学者
  • 对湘古本、桂林古本等“古本伤寒”感兴趣的读者
  • 中医文献学、医史专业的研究生与教师
  • 希望对照宋本查考佚文佚方的临床中医师

Not a good fit for

  • 零基础、想入门学习《伤寒论》的初学者
  • 只想要白话讲解与方剂速查的实用型读者
  • 对版本真伪之争不感兴趣、嫌考据枯燥的读者

Reading tips

  1. 先备一册通行宋本《伤寒论》,边读边对照,才能体会“订误”之用意。
  2. 阅读前略知湘古本、桂林古本的来历与真伪争议,可避免把佚文当作定论。
  3. 把佚方与《金匮要略》《千金翼方》相关方互参,注意周氏按语的取舍。
  4. 本书篇幅不大,宜精读细校,不宜通读快翻。

Contents

  1. Volume One: Pulse Method and Cold Damage Preface
  2. Volume Two: Warm Disease, Summerheat Stroke, Heat Disease, Dampness Disease, and Diagnosis and Treatment of Cold Damage
  3. Volume Three: The Six Channels of Cold Damage and the Various "May and May Not" Chapters
  4. Appendix: 165 Lost Passages
  5. Appendix: 79 Corrections to the Received Text
  6. Appendix: Lost Formulas (approx. 80)

FAQ

《伤寒汲古》是一本什么性质的书?
它是周岐隐1932年编成、1933年由四明怡怡书屋铅印的伤寒学专著,以湘古本《伤寒杂病论》校勘宋本《伤寒论》,辑录佚文、订误与佚方,属于校勘性文献,而非通俗讲义。
书里说的“湘古本”指什么?
指1932年湖南何芸樵(何键)印行的十六卷本《伤寒杂病论》,世称湘古本。其真伪在学界长期存在争议,读者宜持审慎态度看待其中条文。
全书收录了多少条佚文和佚方?
各资料记载佚文一百六十五条、订误七十九条;佚方则有八十首与八十八首两种说法,差异源于统计口径与传本不同。
现在还能买到这本书吗?
原1933年铅印本已成稀见民国医籍,多见于图书馆与旧书拍卖;坊间流通的多为影印或复印本,购买时需注意版本来源与清晰度。

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

Top rated in the same category