The Study of Benevolence

谭嗣同Sep 2024

4.4

Word count: 55K words
Chapters: 55

Summary

This is a philosophical work by the modern Chinese thinker Tan Sitong, written in installments between —. The book consists of chapters in total. Taking Buddhist philosophy as its theoretical framework and blending traditional Chinese learning with Western scholarship, it seeks to fuse religion, philosophy, and science into one, and under the banner of "shattering the net" it exerted enormous influence among late Qing reformists and revolutionaries committed to remaking China; contemporaries hailed it as "the bible of the reform movement."

The book's main content is an attack on the autocratic system of feudal society that promoted the Three Bonds and Five Constant Virtues, and an advocacy of bourgeois notions of equality and democracy; it champions reform and political change and the development of a capitalist economy. The author's critique of the old thought and old traditions under feudal autocratic rule prepares the ground for advocating reform and the development of a capitalist economy; in turn, the advocacy of Western capitalist politics and economics deepens the critique of monarchical autocracy and the doctrines of the bonds and constants. The book's anti-feudal radicalism had a positive influence on the bourgeois revolutionary democrats.

Editor's review

Renxue is Tan Sitong's most incisive intellectual text: framed by Buddhist philosophy, blending traditional Chinese learning with Western thought, it attempts to fuse religion, philosophy, and science into one. What gives the book its force is less its systematic construction than its critical stance of "shattering the net": its frontal assault on the Three Bonds and Five Constant Virtues and monarchical autocracy and its advocacy of equality, democracy, and a capitalist economy reinforce each other, forming a radical edge rarely seen in late Qing intellectual history. It circulated widely among reformists and revolutionaries and was regarded as a spiritual clarion call for reform. Reading it today has two values: first, understanding how late Qing intellectuals struggled to graft Western learning onto traditional resources; second, sensing the intellectual temperature and limitations of modern China's critique of the old order. It suits slow reading; do not demand word-by-word comprehension—first grasp the main thread of "shattering the net," then return to the tension between its Buddhist arguments and political propositions to better appreciate the book's historical weight.

Who it's for

A good fit for

Readers interested in modern Chinese intellectual history and the Reform Movement
Scholars and students studying the intersection of late Qing philosophy, Buddhism, and Western learning
Readers seeking to understand the origins of traditional critique and ideas of democracy and equality
Those who enjoy reading modern classics in the original and taking intellectual-history notes

Not a good fit for

Readers expecting light introductory fare or popular narrative history
Beginners lacking modern history background and unwilling to engage with classical Chinese and Buddhist concepts
Readers who want ready-made conclusions and dislike speculative reading

Reading tips

Read the table of contents and preface first to grasp the main thread of "shattering the net," then read chapter by chapter, avoiding getting bogged down in Buddhist terminology at the outset.
Keep a sheet of paper to record the author's arguments on the Three Bonds and Five Constant Virtues, monarchical autocracy, and equality and democracy, and to map the logic of his critique.
Read against the historical background of late Qing reform and revolution to understand why the book's propositions had such enormous influence at the time.
When encountering passages blending Buddhist and Western thought, skim first; after finishing the book, return to the difficult points.

版权信息
自序
二十七界说
仁学一
一
二
三
四
五
六
七
八
九
十
十一
十二
十三
十四
十五
十六
十七
十八
十九
二十
二十一
二十二
二十三
二十四
二十五
二十六
二十七
二十八
二十九
三十
仁学二
三十一
三十二
三十三
三十四
三十五
三十六
三十七
三十八
三十九
四十
四十一
四十二
四十三
四十四
四十五
四十六
四十七
四十八
四十九
五十

FAQ

Can I understand Renxue without a background in Buddhism?

Yes, but adjust your expectations. The book uses Buddhist philosophy as its theoretical framework and contains many technical terms; on a first reading, do not demand word-by-word comprehension. It is advisable first to grasp the main thread of the author's critique of the Three Bonds and Five Constant Virtues and his advocacy of equality and democracy; skim the Buddhist argumentation for now and return to it after finishing the book—understanding will come more smoothly.

What is the relationship between this book and the Reform Movement?

Renxue was written as late Qing reformist thought was rising. Under the banner of "shattering the net," it attacked feudal autocracy and old ritual codes and advocated equality, democracy, and the development of a capitalist economy. It had great influence among reformists and revolutionaries committed to remaking China; contemporaries hailed it as "the bible of the reform movement." But it is a work of thought, not an operational manual for reform.

What is the significance of reading Renxue today?

Its significance lies mainly not in offering ready-made answers but in showing how modern Chinese intellectuals mobilized traditional resources and Western learning to critique the old order. Reading it helps understand the reception of ideas of equality and democracy in modern China and reveals the intellectual tensions and historical limitations behind radical critique—valuable for understanding modern intellectual transformation.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

谭嗣同 Author

Tan Sitong is an important figure in the history of modern Chinese thought; because publicly available material on his life is limited, this profile does not dwell on biographical detail. His best-known work is Renxue (An Exposition of Benevolence), a book that gives concentrated expression to his philosophical reflection and critical spirit and holds a distinctive place among works of Eastern philosophy. In style, Tan Sitong writes with intensity and a strongly speculative bent, often carrying his argument forward through sharp value judgments rather than laborious textual scholarship, so that the writing has a direct, outspoken force. The questions raised in Renxue concern the tension between traditional thought and a consciousness of change, and its influence extends beyond the scope of a purely philosophical treatise, offering an important text for understanding the intellectual atmosphere of the late Qing. At present the collection holds only one work by him, Renxue, which readers may use as an entry point for appreciating Tan Sitong's intellectual edge and manner of expression.