Annotated Reference to the Doctrine of the Mean cover

Annotated Reference to the Doctrine of the Mean

Rating 4.3
Word count
44K words
Chapters
6
ISBN
9787206083303

Tags

Summary

Annotated Reflections on The Doctrine of the Mean is the fruit of Mr. Chen Zhu's lectures on The Doctrine of the Mean at Jinan University and Daxia University. The author mostly annotates The Doctrine of the Mean with his own insights; where he has nothing new to offer, he still adopts Zheng Xuan's annotations, and he also selects and records the theories of various schools, especially those of modern scholars Dai Zhen, Kang Youwei, Ma Qichang, and his teacher Mr. Tang Weizhi, whose theories are recorded in great number for reference. At the same time, Annotated Reflections on The Doctrine of the Mean includes A General Exposition of The Doctrine of the Mean, which Chen Zhu wrote when he taught at Nanyang University in the past; it is truly a classic text for studying The Doctrine of the Mean.

Editor's review

Zhongyong Zhucan is a work of in-depth annotation and personal commentary on the Confucian core classic The Doctrine of the Mean by the modern scholar Chen Zhu. Unlike traditional collected commentaries or philological glosses, the book's greatest distinguishing feature is that Chen Zhu, under the name "annotation and commentary," both cites important commentaries from successive dynasties (such as those of Zheng Xuan and Zhu Xi) extensively and integrates his own distinctive views and reflections on his era as a broadly learned scholar of the Republican period, creating an interpretive style that combines "I annotate the Six Classics" with "the Six Classics annotate me." His analysis of core propositions such as "what Heaven confers is called nature, following nature is called the Way, cultivating the Way is called teaching" not only sorts out the interpretive lineage since Song-Ming Neo-Confucianism but also attempts to connect traditional learning of mind and nature with the spiritual situation of modern people, reflecting an effort to make ancient wisdom "come alive" again in a modern context. Chen Zhu was enormously learned and versed in the classics and histories; his annotations often make connections across fields, citing the Book of Songs, Book of Documents, Book of Changes and Book of Rites to corroborate one another, demonstrating the internal coherence of the Confucian intellectual system. Reading this book not only gives a more solid understanding of the subtle meanings of the Zhongyong text but also offers a glimpse of how a traditional scholar in an era of intense interaction between Chinese and Western scholarship used deep learning as a foundation for creative interpretation of the classics. Its value lies not only in the transmission of knowledge but also in demonstrating a serious yet lively attitude toward dialogue with the classics.

Who it's for

A good fit for

  • Readers who find the original text of the Confucian classic Zhongyong confusing and hope for a clear, in-depth introduction
  • Scholars and students researching Chinese philosophy and intellectual history, especially Song-Ming Neo-Confucianism and modern classical interpretation
  • Classics enthusiasts who are not satisfied with simple vernacular translations and want to understand important commentaries from successive dynasties and different interpretive perspectives
  • Readers interested in Republican-era scholarship and how scholars of the time responded to traditional and modern issues

Not a good fit for

  • Readers seeking only a simple vernacular translation of the Zhongyong and not interested in exploring various commentaries and doctrinal analysis
  • Readers hoping for an interpretation of the Zhongyong applied to modern business management or success literature

Reading tips

  1. It is advisable first to read through the original text of the Zhongyong (included in this book) to form a preliminary impression of its overall framework and core concepts, then read Chen Zhu's commentary closely.
  2. While reading, note which parts are quotations of earlier commentaries (such as Zheng Xuan's and Zhu Xi's) and which are Chen Zhu's own "commentary" (his insights and elaborations).
  3. The book involves a large number of traditional academic terms and citations; keeping a copy of the Four Books or a basic dictionary of Chinese studies as a reference tool will help with understanding.

About the publisher

Guangxi Normal University Press China · Founded in 1986

Guangxi Normal University Press is a publisher known for literature, foreign literature and history titles. Its 1,175 books in the database show a solid accumulation in classics and prose collections, including foreign literary works such as Les Fleurs du mal: Annotated Poems of Baudelaire, Snow Country, Dubliners and The Wild Palms, as well as modern prose compilations like The Complete Prose of Zhou Zuoren. History and philosophy also hold a notable share, with titles such as Running Dogs: Clerks and Runners in Qing County Yamen and The History and Thought of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom reflecting attention to Qing local administration and modern history. In art literature there is the 16-volume Ten Bamboo Studio Painting and Calligraphy Manual. Its author resources include foreign writers Charles Baudelaire and Yasunari Kawabata, translators and annotators Liu Nanqi and Zou Bo, and scholars such as Zhong Shuhe, Bradly W. Reed and You Chenjun. As public information is limited, this characterization is based only on the books in the database, which together present a profile balancing Chinese and foreign literary classics with academic works in the humanities and social sciences.

Contents

  1. 版权信息
  2. 出版说明
  3. 自序
  4. 说明
  5. 中庸注参
  6. 附:中庸通义

FAQ

What are the main differences between Chen Zhu's Zhongyong Zhucan and Zhu Xi's Zhongyong Zhangju?
Zhu Xi's Zhangju is a foundational interpretation of the Song Neo-Confucian system, focusing on constructing the philosophical system of "principle" and "nature" and elaborating on mind-nature cultivation such as "watchfulness over oneself alone" and "before and after the arising of feeling." Chen Zhu's Zhucan has a modern scholarly character; while respecting traditional authorities such as Zhu Xi's commentary, it cites Han and Tang ancient commentaries and other schools more extensively and integrates his own scholarly insights. Its vision is broader and it has a certain synthesizing and reflective quality.
Is this book suitable for readers with no foundation in Chinese studies?
It is somewhat challenging. The book directly includes the classical Chinese original and a large number of classical Chinese annotations. Although the language of Chen Zhu's "commentary" is relatively plain, readers still need basic classical Chinese reading ability or a determination to study classical Chinese and the arguments in depth through this book. It is better suited as an advanced reading text.
What are the features of this book's edited publication?
The book is published by Guangxi Normal University Press and is a modern edition of Chen Zhu's works. It usually includes the editor's notes, which help in understanding the textual source and editorial principles. Some editions may include related research articles as appendices, providing readers with more background for understanding Chen Zhu's scholarship and this book.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

陈柱 Author

Chen Zhu's biography, including his life dates and nationality, is not well documented in publicly available sources. The library currently holds seven of his works, which concentrate on traditional Chinese scholarship and literary studies. On the one hand, he wrote on the Schools of Thought and Confucian classics, including Chen Zhu on the Schools of Thought, The Original Classics Library: An Introduction to the Schools of Thought, and An Annotated Commentary on the Doctrine of the Mean, works that trace early Chinese intellectual traditions and offer annotation and interpretation. On the other hand, he examined the history of prose in A History of Chinese Prose and Chen Zhu on the History of Chinese Prose, surveying the development of Chinese prose in a historical manner. His works appear in series such as The Original Classics Library and are classified under Eastern philosophy, classic works, history, and literary appreciation. The library also lists Commercial Bank Practice: Cases and Analysis, whose subject differs markedly and may belong to a namesake author; readers should distinguish between them.

More by the same author

Top rated in the same category