Watson Refuted

Francis, Samuel W. (Samuel Ward), 1835-1886Project Gutenberg · United StatesDec 2019

2.6

Word count: 175K words
Chapters: 18

Summary

Project Gutenberg was the first provider of free electronic books, or eBooks. Michael Hart, founder of Project Gutenberg, invented eBooks in 1971 and his memory continues to inspire the creation of eBooks and related technologies today.Watson Refuted by Samuel W. FrancisAuthor: Francis, Samuel W. (Samuel Ward), 1835-1886,Language: English, Class: BL: Philosophy, Psychology, Religion: Religion: General, Miscellaneous and Atheism, Release Date: Oct 8, 2012

Editor's review

Watson Refuted by Samuel W. Francis is a religious polemical text classified under general topics in philosophy, psychology, and religion. The title alone shows that it rebuts the views of a certain “Watson,” belonging to the tradition of polemical pamphlets common in the nineteenth-century English-speaking world. The value of such works lies not in literary quality but in presenting the argumentative methods, rhetorical strategies, and immediacy of intellectual debate of the time. Readers can observe how the polemicist defines concepts, cites authorities, and organizes counterevidence, which is of documentary value for those studying the history of religious thought or the polemical genre. Because it is a public-domain e-book without a modern introduction, readers must supply the historical context themselves; without knowing the background of the person being rebutted, the argument may seem to jump. Overall, it is suitable as supplementary reading for the study of intellectual history and religious polemics, not as an introductory religious text.

Who it's for

A good fit for

Researchers in the history of religious thought interested in nineteenth-century English-language polemical texts
Readers interested in the polemical genre and rhetorical strategies
Philosophy or theology students using it for training in reading historical sources
Independent researchers who enjoy public-domain documents and are willing to research background themselves

Not a good fit for

Beginners seeking systematic introductory knowledge of religion
General readers expecting a literary reading experience
People unwilling to research historical background and hoping for modern annotations

Reading tips

First find out who “Watson” is and what his main views were, then read the rebuttal; the argument will be much clearer
Mark the argumentative structure as you read: the opponent's claims, the author's rebuttal, and the cited evidence, and make a simple table
Read alongside similar polemical pamphlets of the same period and note similarities and differences in rhetorical patterns

About the publisher

Project Gutenberg United States · Founded in 1971

Project Gutenberg is a digital publishing project focused on public-domain ebooks. Its publishing direction centers on classic literary works whose copyright has expired, covering genres such as poetry, drama, fiction, and epic. Representative books include Lyrical Ballads by Wordsworth and Coleridge, Proust's Du côté de chez Swann, Shakespeare's Macbeth and The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, Homer's The Iliad, Dante's La Divina Comèdia: Purgatòri, Cervantes's The History of Don Quixote, Volume 2, and Grahame's The Wind in the Willows. Its author resources consist mainly of classic Western writers such as Wordsworth, Proust, Shakespeare, Homer, Dante, Cervantes, Grahame, and Tolstoy. Its publishing feature is the provision of freely accessible ebooks in EPUB and Kindle formats; it is not a traditional publisher, and publicly available information is limited.

FAQ

Who is this book rebutting?

Watson in the title is the person being rebutted, but the materials do not elaborate on his identity or specific views. Readers need to consult reference works on the history of religious thought or contemporary documents to fully understand the polemical context.

Can I understand it without a theology background?

You can read it, but the depth of understanding will be limited. It is advisable to first acquire some general knowledge of nineteenth-century English-speaking religious controversies, then focus on the author's argumentative method rather than rushing to judge whether the views are right or wrong.

Is it suitable as an introduction to religion?

No. It is a polemical text that presupposes familiarity with the background of the controversy and lacks systematic introduction. Introductory readers are better off starting with general histories before returning to primary polemical material like this.

Comments

Find this book

This site is an index: you start “Search all sources” in your browser, and the entries it lists all point to third-party sites; please judge their availability yourself.

About the author

Francis, Samuel W. (Samuel Ward), 1835-1886 Author · American · 1835–1886

Samuel W. Francis (1835–1886) was an American physician and inventor. Public information about him is limited, and few details of his life have come down to us. He held a number of patents and, alongside his medical practice, often wrote on medical and scientific subjects, showing an interest that led from clinical practice toward technical improvement. Two of his works are held in this collection: Watson Refuted and A Christmas Story. Judging by its title, the former is likely a work of argument or rebuttal, while the latter is a narrative piece on a Christmas theme. The two are far apart in subject, suggesting that his writing was not confined to medicine but extended to general essays and stories as well. On the whole, he was a nineteenth-century American author who pursued medicine, invention, and writing side by side; his output was small, and knowledge of him and his work still rests largely on scattered records.